Why SpaceX stocks fell after the historic Starship catch
SpaceX stocks fell about 1.8% on Monday even after Starship's historic upper-stage catch, as investors weighed an incomplete booster recovery against rich valuation concerns. Shares of Space Exploration Technologies (NASDAQ:SPCX) traded near $136.65, while bulls cheered a reusability breakthrough and bears still see deep downside.
Key Takeaways
- Starship Flight 15 achieved the first catch of an orbital-class upper stage; the Super Heavy booster aborted and was lost.
- SPCX was down roughly 1.77% near $136.65 Monday, about 15% below its first-day close.
- Bank of America kept a Buy rating and $275 target; a Seeking Alpha analysis argues about 69% downside.
- Q3 revenue surged 161% year over year to $14.58 billion, but CapEx and concentration risks still worry skeptics.
What Happened on Starship Flight 15?
On Friday's Flight 15, SpaceX caught Starship's upper stage with the launch tower after a 22.5-hour mission that deployed 26 Starlink V3 satellites—the ship's longest flight yet, according to Benzinga.
Barron's called the tower catch an amazing engineering feat. The planned double catch failed: Super Heavy aborted over guidance, navigation, and low-fuel issues, then exploded before hitting the Gulf. Epstein argued that aborting a risky catch is what regulators want to see.
Why Are SpaceX Stocks Down After the Catch?
The milestone did not spark a Monday rally. SPCX slipped 1.77% to about $136.65, within a post-IPO range of $104.83 to $225.64 and still about 15% under its first-day close.
That gap between viral success and price action is the story. Bears of Wall Street on Seeking Alpha rate the name a Sell, citing CapEx guidance of $35–$40 billion for the fourth quarter, a customer that is 34.5% of revenue and can exit agreements from 2027, and a model putting fair value near $43.52—about 69% below recent levels around $135.
For more market puzzles and unexplained moves, see our True Crime & Unsolved Mysteries desk.
Can SpaceX Stocks Still Double From Here?
Bank of America Securities analyst Ronald J. Epstein maintained a Buy rating and $275 price target—about 101% upside from Monday's price—calling the ship catch "the missing piece of the reusability puzzle."
Epstein said both halves of a fully reusable orbital rocket can work, and that the harder ship catch is done. He also noted back-to-back orbital successes after September's Flight 14 and said the mission showed Starship can do real work for Artemis-linked goals. Next proofs: a full double catch, re-flying recovered hardware, a Florida Starship launch, and a possible upgraded V3 Super Heavy re-flight by the end of 2026.
Until those land, SpaceX stocks sit between a historic engineering win and a valuation fight Wall Street has not settled.