True Crime & Unsolved Mysteries · Diana Graves · 14 November 2026

Two Putnam County schoolgirls cases remain unsolved decades later

Two Putnam County schoolgirls cases remain unsolved decades later

Two Putnam County schoolgirls vanished in the mid-1990s: Josette Wright, 12, in October 1994, and Robin Murphy, 17, in April 1995. Wright's remains were found in 1995; Murphy has never been located. Wrongful convictions later collapsed, and neither case has produced a lasting conviction—both remain unsolved.

ABC's 20/20 episode "Hiding Beneath the Surface: The Putnam County School Girls," which aired Nov. 13, 2026, has put fresh national attention on these true crime and unsolved mysteries from Carmel, New York.

Key Takeaways

What happened to the two Putnam County schoolgirls?

Wright was reported missing on Oct. 4, 1994, after she failed to return home the night before, according to reporting that cites the National Registry of Exonerations. Searches yielded little until a hunter found her skeletal remains in the woods in November 1995.

Items recovered at the scene included nylon rope, a tied bra, underwear, and a hologram eye pendant. Trial testimony described remains consistent with possible asphyxiation, though a definitive cause of death could not be established from the skeletal remains.

Murphy disappeared on April 9, 1995, after meeting a friend at the ShopRite plaza in Carmel, ABC News reported. Days later, searchers found her work schedule and paystub in nearby woods; her wallet and ID turned up near a dumpster behind the shopping center. No one has been arrested in her case, and she remains missing more than 30 years later.

Why were earlier convictions in Wright's case overturned?

In July 1996, DiPippo and Krivak—then teens themselves at the time of Wright's killing—were charged with her rape and murder. They were convicted in separate 1997 trials of second-degree murder and first-degree rape and each sentenced to 25 years to life.

Key witnesses later recanted, alleging police pressure. Krivak's defense said a confession followed hours of questioning after he was allegedly told he failed a polygraph. DiPippo maintained he was living in Connecticut and denied involvement.

DiPippo was acquitted at a third trial in 2016 after jurors heard inmate testimony linking Howard Gombert to the crime; he later received multimillion-dollar wrongful-imprisonment settlements. Krivak was acquitted at a 2023 retrial and also secured substantial settlements. With those convictions gone, Wright's murder is again officially unsolved.

Who is Howard Gombert, and why are answers still missing?

Gombert worked at a laundromat in the same plaza where Murphy worked. In 1995 he told police he briefly met Murphy the night she vanished, then saw her walk toward the restaurant where her boyfriend worked. He denied knowing more.

After a 2000 arrest for sexually assaulting his former girlfriend, police searched his home and said DNA on underwear matched Murphy. Gombert has offered conflicting explanations for the items. A witness reportedly placed Wright in his car the day she disappeared, and an inmate later alleged Gombert admitted involvement—claims Gombert disputes.

He has never been charged in either girl's case. In an email to 20/20, he denied any role in Murphy's disappearance. Families and investigators are still waiting for answers that have eluded Putnam County for three decades.

← Open in blast feed