Taste test this fantastic 18-year-old Phoenix pour
Heaven Hill Phoenix is a new 18-year-old bourbon that blends post-fire whiskey with a splash of legendary 30-year-old pre-fire spirit, bottled at 107 proof and scoring 98 in a recent taste test this fantastic release already commands secondary prices well above its $325 launch sticker—and collectors are taking notice.
Key Takeaways
- Phoenix marks 30 years since Heaven Hill’s November 7, 1996 Bardstown fire, which destroyed 100,000 barrels.
- The bottle mixes 2008-distilled 18-year bourbon from heavy-char barrels with some 30-year-old pre-fire whiskey.
- Robb Report critic Jonah Flicker scored it 98, praising leather, oak, cherry cobbler, and burnt vanilla notes.
- MSRP is $325 in select markets; secondary prices already run about triple, with auctions near double.
- Flicker says buy under $500—the modern whiskey’s quality, not just the pre-fire lore, drives the hype.
What makes Heaven Hill Phoenix a collector’s bottle?
On November 7, 1996, fire tore through seven Heaven Hill rickhouses in Bardstown, Kentucky, wiping out 100,000 barrels valued at about $30 million—roughly two percent of the world’s whiskey supply then. Pre-fire Heaven Hill stock has been prized on secondary and auction markets ever since.
Phoenix is built to mark that anniversary. According to Robb Report’s Taste Test, the blend includes some 30-year-old pre-fire whiskey alongside the 18-year base, though Heaven Hill will not say how much. Scarcity and story alone can turn a release into a unicorn; Phoenix arrives with both.
No lives were lost in 1996, the house yeast survived, and rivals including Jim Beam and Brown-Forman helped the company recover. Heaven Hill later bought Bernheim in Louisville and, last year, opened Heaven Hill Springs Distillery in Bardstown. The mashbill also shifted from 75 percent corn and 13 percent rye to 78 percent corn and 10 percent rye—another reason pre- and post-fire whiskey can taste different.
How does this fantastic 18-year-old bourbon taste?
The base whiskey was distilled in 2008 and aged in heavy-char barrels, then bottled at 107 proof. Flicker calls it a deep, rich sipper: leather, oak, cherry cobbler, pecan, fig, over-ripe apple, and burnt vanilla, with a touch of warming heat from the higher proof.
He ranks it above recent Elijah Craig single-barrel 15- and 21-year releases and argues the bottle would still excel as straight 18-year post-fire Heaven Hill. The pre-fire drop may sell the story; the modern whiskey, he says, is what keeps you pouring.
Is the $325 price tag still worth chasing?
Phoenix hit select markets at the end of last month for $325. It is already trading at about triple that on the secondary market and roughly double on auction sites. Flicker’s advice is clear: if you can find a bottle for less than $500, it is worth the chase.
Collectors who stack rare bottles often pair the hunt with lasting luxury—think age-worthy pieces from houses like Berluti and Chopard, or a private lakeside stay such as The Lakes by YOO’s new three-bed cabins on 850 acres in the Cotswolds. For more high-end lifestyle coverage, browse BlasterPost’s Luxury Real Estate & Dream Homes hub.
Score: 98—“In the Pantheon,” in Flicker’s scale. The fire story opens the door; the pour is why Phoenix looks destined for collector shelves.