Taste test this espresso martini whiskey: a decadent sip
Taste test this espresso martini-inspired whiskey and you will find Beverly Cafe, a 110-proof bourbon-rye blend finished in coffee liqueur casks that Robb Report scored 86. Priced at $140 and limited to 550 bottles, it is a rich, dessert-friendly sipper—not a flavored whiskey—that stands out for after-dinner drinking.
Key Takeaways
- Beverly Cafe is a bourbon and rye blend finished in Black Hjerte coffee liqueur casks and bottled at 110 proof.
- Robb Report critic Jonah Flicker scored it 86 and called it a rich, decadent dessert sipper.
- The release is limited to 550 bottles and retails for about $140.
- It is not flavored whiskey; the coffee character comes from cask finishing alone.
What is Beverly Cafe and who makes it?
Beverly Cafe comes from Beverly Spirits, an American whiskey brand founded in 2022 by Andrew Borenzweig. The liquid is distilled and produced at Cedar Ridge Distillery in Iowa.
According to Robb Report's Taste Test review, the whiskey was inspired by a cocktail called Serenade to a Stranger that Borenzweig tried at Gucci Giardino in Osaka, which used Beverly High Rye as its base.
Back in Los Angeles, he built a tribute using a signature 50/50 bourbon-rye blend plus straight bourbon and rye from MGP in Indiana. The final mashbill across those four components is 54 percent rye, 38 percent corn, and 8 percent malted barley.
How does a taste test this espresso whiskey actually drink?
The whiskey spent six months in Barrel-Aged Black Hjerte coffee liqueur casks that previously aged bourbon, and six months in Blood Orange Black Hjerte casks from Los Angeles brand Laurel Canyon Spirits. Those finishes were blended together and bottled at 110 proof.
Flicker says coffee jumps out first, followed by dark chocolate, maple, brown sugar, cinnamon, and molasses. The blood orange finish is subtle, leaving only a slight citrus tinge on the back end.
He does not think the flavor fully emulates an Espresso Martini. Instead, it feels closer to an intense, high-end bottled-cocktail style that still drinks like whiskey—neat or over ice—and pairs well with dessert.
Is the $140 bottle worth buying?
At $140 for a 550-bottle run, Beverly Cafe sits in limited, higher-end territory. Flicker's 86 score falls in Robb Report's "Very Good" band: delicious enough to buy, but not a secondary-market chase piece.
You can purchase it directly from the brand or at select retailers, including high-end Los Angeles grocer Erewhon. With such a small allotment, bottles will not linger.
For readers who collect luxurious pours the way others collect luxury real estate and dream homes, this is a niche after-dinner bottle meant to stand out on the bar cart—not an everyday pour.