Susan Smith's ex barely recalls sons as she seeks parole
David Smith, ex-husband of Susan Smith, says he can barely remember their murdered sons Michael and Alex as she faces a second parole hearing on Nov. 19. He wants her kept in prison for life, calling any release an injustice after she drowned the boys in 1994.
Key Takeaways
- David Smith, 56, tells PEOPLE he has almost no memories of sons Michael, 3, and Alex, 14 months, killed by Susan Smith in 1994.
- Susan Smith faces the South Carolina Board of Paroles and Pardons on Thursday, Nov. 19, after a unanimous denial in 2024.
- David says he wants her “in prison until she dies,” arguing 32 years have not eased the heartache.
- She drowned the boys by letting her car roll into John D. Long Lake in Union, South Carolina, after a false carjacking claim.
What did Susan Smith do to her sons?
In October 1994, Susan Smith claimed a Black man carjacked her at a traffic light in Union, South Carolina, and drove off with 3-year-old Michael and 14-month-old Alex still in the car. For nine days she pleaded publicly for their return while David sat beside her.
She later confessed she had strapped the boys into their car seats, put her Mazda in neutral, and let it roll into John D. Long Lake. Prosecutors argued she killed them at least partly because a man she was seeing did not want a relationship with a woman who had children. Her defense called it a failed suicide attempt amid severe depression.
Convicted of two counts of murder in 1995, she received a life sentence with parole eligibility after 30 years under then-state law. Coverage of the case remains a staple of true crime reporting.
Why can David Smith barely remember Michael and Alex?
More than three decades later, David, now 56, told PEOPLE that vivid memories of the boys are gone. “I remember maybe quotes that they used to say, a few of those,” he said. “But memories, there aren’t any.”
He still recalls Michael’s childish speech—calling 101 Dalmatians “Domashafens” and Alex his “brudder.” He keeps only a few photos at home with wife Tiffany, avoiding a shrine he says would be unhealthy. Psychiatrists once told him the blank spots may be a defense against unbearable pain.
David learned of the confession on live television at his then in-laws’ home. “I found out that she killed our children on live TV,” he has said.
Will Susan Smith get parole this time?
The seven-member South Carolina Board of Paroles and Pardons will hear her request Thursday. In 2024 the board unanimously denied release after she testified by video that she knew what she did was “horrible” and would change it if she could.
David plans to oppose her again. “If I have a choice, I’d want her to stay in prison until she dies,” he told CNN. “32 years hasn’t changed the heartache.” He fears this hearing could be the one that frees her and calls release “an injustice” to his sons.
Tiffany and relatives will stand with him. Strangers still leave toys at the boys’ gravesite and lake memorial—a gesture David says makes his “heart smile.”