Why Sonny Dykes has likely earned another year at TCU
Sonny Dykes faces real fan heat at TCU after a 5-5 start and a sputtering offense, but he is not in immediate jeopardy. Dallas Morning News argues he has earned at least another year after back-to-back nine-win seasons and a spring extension, even as Texas writers debate firing calls for Dykes and Mike Elko.
Key Takeaways
- Sonny Dykes has TCU at 5-5 entering Week 12, with all five losses by one score and an offense that has drawn heavy criticism.
- Dallas Morning News analysis says Dykes has earned at least one more year after consecutive nine-win seasons and a national title-game run in 2022.
- A Hear Me Out panel of Texas sportswriters is weighing whether firing calls aimed at Dykes and Mike Elko are fair.
- If TCU did move on, speculative replacement names include Sonny Cumbie, GJ Kinne, Kenny Perry, and Lincoln Riley.
The noise around Fort Worth is loud, but the case for keeping Sonny Dykes is still grounded in recent production. He was hired in 2022 to replace Gary Patterson, then immediately won 13 games and guided the Horned Frogs to the national championship game.
Since that breakthrough, TCU is 2-0 in bowl games and has averaged eight wins per season, according to reporting that also notes restless fans after this year's mid-season stall. For readers who track career leverage the way investors track cash flow, that resume still matters — and so does patience when a short stretch of results gets over-weighted. More on long-game decision making lives in our Wealth Hacks & Passive Income hub.
Are Elko and Dykes actually in firing range?
On the Hear Me Out vodcast, sportswriters and columnists from four major Texas newspapers — including Kevin Sherrington — debated whether calls to dismiss Texas A&M coach Mike Elko and TCU coach Sonny Dykes were warranted or fair. The same episode also touched Baylor's already open coaching job, the Texas-Arkansas rivalry, and the week's slate of games.
That framing is important: the panel treated the heat as a live media debate, not a settled administrative outcome. Yahoo Sports carried the episode roundup, underscoring how quickly "hot seat" talk spreads when two high-profile Texas programs stumble in the same window. You can read the panel teaser via Yahoo Sports.
For Dykes specifically, the counterargument from Dallas Morning News is blunt. It is hard to see a coach coming off back-to-back nine-win seasons — and only four years removed from the school's only national championship game appearance — as truly disposable midstream.
Why does Sonny Dykes still have a strong case to stay?
Context cuts both ways. Dykes' five losses this season came by margins of 5, 8, 4, 7, and 1 points. That is not a team getting blown out weekly; it is a team living on the wrong side of one-score games.
Critics still have a clear target: the offense. Dallas Morning News notes Dykes is on his third offensive coordinator in five seasons, or four if you count A.J. Ricker, who served as co-OC before being fired after the West Virginia loss. Gordon Sammis was hired as OC this year partly to jump-start the run game. That plan has not delivered as hoped.
Regardless of who held the coordinator title, the piece argues the offense has always belonged to Dykes, a Hal Mumme Air Raid disciple also shaped by Mike Leach. Against power-conference foes, TCU has averaged 17.5 points — a figure the column uses to illustrate how far the attack has drifted from Air Raid norms.
Still, the same analysis stresses the Frogs were not that far from Big 12 contention. Roster-spend reporting cited in the column places Texas Tech ahead of TCU, with one competing report ranking the Frogs near the bottom of the league in spending. Either way, resources and tight losses complicate the "fire him now" narrative.
Personality flashpoints also fuel fan frustration. The Dallas column acknowledges Dykes is not Spike Dykes, points to the SMU rivalry rupture, and notes a local newspaper ban as self-inflicted optics. It also notes he teaches a night class at TCU — a detail offered as evidence he is not simply a distant hire.
The bottom line from that piece: Sonny Dykes has earned the right to see more of the extension his boss gave him last spring. If next season fails too, then TCU can revisit the decision. Until then, "be careful what you wish for" is the explicit warning, recalling leaner eras before Franchione and Patterson raised the program's floor.
Who would replace Sonny Dykes if TCU made a change?
BetMGM's speculative board starts from the same 5-5 snapshot and "completely broken" offense chatter, then lists names fans might hear if Fort Worth pivoted. The first is Sonny Cumbie, a former TCU offensive coordinator under Patterson who later became Louisiana Tech's head coach and helped restore that program as a Group of 5 force after an eight-win 2025.
GJ Kinne is framed as a rising Texas coach whose offense could address TCU's biggest on-field problem. After stops at Incarnate Word and Texas State — including Texas State's move into the Pac-12 — Kinne is cast as an automatic interview candidate with local recruiting juice.
Kenny Perry, an associate head coach at Texas Tech and a longtime Texas football lifer, is presented as a steady, connection-heavy hire. The caveat is optics: firing a coach who reached a national title game four years ago for a first-time NCAA head coach is a hard sell.
Lincoln Riley is the long-shot "hear me out" name. The argument rests on Big Ten travel fatigue at USC, booster noise, and Riley's Big 12 roots as a Texas native who played and first coached in the league — not on any confirmed interest from either side.
None of those names changes the near-term read from the Dallas column: Sonny Dykes' seat is warm because the offense is cold and the record is .500, but his recent wins, one-score losses, and fresh extension make a mid-cycle firing look more like fan catharsis than a settled institutional plan.
Elko's situation sits in the same conversation cycle without the same detailed public defense in these sources. The Hear Me Out group put both coaches under the same fairness question. For now, the clearest published answer centers on TCU: Dykes has earned another year unless 2027 also goes sideways.