True Crime & Unsolved Mysteries · Nora Whitfield · 8 November 2026

SLED charges Sumter man in multi-county insurance fraud probe

SLED charges Sumter man in multi-county insurance fraud probe

South Carolina's SLED has charged Sumter County man Lonnie Johnson Jr., 35, with forgery and false-claim counts in an ongoing multi-county insurance fraud investigation. Authorities say he submitted falsified physician statements to seek more than $17,000 in Aflac disability benefits. He is the seventh person charged; the state Department of Insurance will prosecute.

Key Takeaways

The arrest adds fresh pressure to a sprawling Midlands true crime case that investigators say spans multiple counties and centers on bogus disability paperwork.

Who was charged in the insurance fraud probe?

According to local reporting and an official SLED news release, Lonnie Johnson Jr. faces two counts of forgery valued at less than $10,000, one count of presenting a false claim for insurance payment valued at $10,000 or more, and one count of presenting a false claim valued at more than $2,000 but less than $10,000.

SLED said the charges were filed Wednesday, Oct. 28, 2026. Johnson was booked into the Clarendon County Detention Center.

Manning Live reported he is the seventh person charged. Five people were charged Oct. 14 and a sixth on Oct. 27.

What do warrants say about the alleged claims?

Arrest warrants cited by Manning Live say Johnson obtained a short-term disability policy through Aflac on or about March 1, 2025, after an all-terrain vehicle incident in Clarendon County.

Investigators allege he later submitted two physicians' statements purportedly from Midlands Ortho & Neurosurgery. The first claim, filed on or about May 23, 2025, allegedly sought more than $10,000; warrants say the facility did not issue the statement and the physician's signature was forged.

A second claim on or about July 22, 2025, allegedly sought about $7,800 and again included a falsified physician statement and forged signature, according to the warrants. Together, authorities say the bids involved more than $17,000 in disability benefits.

How wide is the multi-county investigation?

SLED previously charged six others in the same ongoing investigation. Among them, Manning Live identified Jeanette Nicole Weaver, 40, of Manning, an insurance producer facing 14 counts of fraudulent insurance application by an agent.

Warrants in Weaver's case allege she submitted fraudulent Aflac applications using other people's identifying information, including Social Security numbers and account credentials.

Four other women from Florence, Sumter, Columbia, and Lake City were charged Oct. 14 over alleged fraudulent short-term disability claims, falsified medical records, and forged documents. Robin Latee Smith, 42, of Williamsburg County, was charged Oct. 27 with forgery and presenting a false insurance claim valued between $2,000 and $10,000.

The South Carolina Department of Insurance requested the investigation and will prosecute Johnson's case. SLED says the multi-county insurance fraud probe remains open.

← Open in blast feed