Sarah Michelle Gellar and Freddie Prinze Jr. Relist L.A. Home
Sarah Michelle Gellar and Freddie Prinze Jr. have relisted their Brentwood estate for $9.95 million—a $550,000 price cut from the $10.5 million they sought when the home hit the market in late May. The Hollywood couple bought the Colonial-style spread for $6.1 million in 2013 and have already relocated to Encino with their two children.
Key Takeaways
- The couple cut the asking price to $9.95 million after roughly three months on the market.
- The gated Brentwood home spans about 7,300 square feet with five bedrooms and six bathrooms.
- Gellar and Prinze Jr. purchased the property for $6.1 million and invested in a major renovation.
- They have moved to an Encino residence bought off-market in spring 2025 for about $12.4 million.
- Cindy Ambuehl of Christie's International Real Estate Southern California holds the updated listing.
After three months without a buyer, Sarah Michelle Gellar and Freddie Prinze Jr. are testing a new price point on one of Brentwood's most talked-about celebrity listings. The adjustment signals that even A-list sellers in Los Angeles are recalibrating expectations as luxury inventory sits longer than in recent boom years.
For more on high-profile property moves, browse our Luxury Real Estate & Dream Homes coverage.
Why Did Sarah Michelle Gellar and Freddie Prinze Jr. Cut the Asking Price?
The Buffy the Vampire Slayer star and She's All That heartthrob first listed the rolling-hills property in Lower Mandeville Canyon in late May at $10.5 million, according to Robb Report. With no sale after roughly three months, they trimmed the ask by $550,000 to $9.95 million.
That still represents a substantial gain over the $6.1 million they paid in 2013. The couple extensively renovated the Shain Development-built residence from the early 2000s, upgrading the swimming pool and converting an attic into a teen hangout complete with arcade machines.
What Does the Brentwood Estate Include?
Tucked behind gates on nearly a third of an acre, the white board-and-batten Colonial sits on three levels across roughly 7,300 square feet. Inside are five bedrooms and six bathrooms, wide-plank oak floors, custom millwork, and French doors that open to outdoor living spaces.
A columned portico leads to a double-height foyer flowing into a formal dining room, bookshelf-lined study, and a family room connected to a spacious kitchen with a central eat-in island. A fireside living room adds a wet bar and climatized wine room, while the vaulted primary suite features a makeup vanity between double sinks and balcony access.
The west-facing backyard centers on a heated pool with inset spa, barbecue station, flagstone fire pit, and covered entertaining terrace. An attached two-car garage sits off a streetside driveway.
Where Are Gellar and Prinze Jr. Living Now?
The couple met in 1997 while filming I Know What You Did Last Summer and married in 2002. They have already moved on from Brentwood, relocating with their two children to an Encino property acquired in an off-market deal in spring 2025 for about $12.4 million.
That makes the Mandeville Canyon listing a vacant, move-in-ready trophy home rather than a lived-in family sale—a detail that can appeal to buyers seeking a polished celebrity estate without a long closing timeline.