Sandra Birchmore jury says it's deadlocked in Farwell trial
The Sandra Birchmore jury says it is deadlocked and told a federal judge the split “will not change any time soon,” yet deliberations were ordered to continue. Former Stoughton officer Matthew Farwell faces federal charges tied to Birchmore’s 2021 death, which was first ruled a suicide.
Key Takeaways
- Jurors in Matthew Farwell’s federal trial told the judge they were deadlocked and that the impasse “will not change any time soon.”
- U.S. District Judge Denise Casper directed the panel to keep deliberating Tuesday, without issuing a “dynamite charge.”
- Farwell, 41, a former Stoughton police officer, is charged with killing a witness or victim and causing the death of Birchmore’s unborn child.
- Birchmore, 23 and pregnant, was found dead in her Canton, Mass., apartment in 2021; her death was initially ruled a suicide.
- Prosecutors allege Farwell killed her and staged the scene; his attorney maintains she died by suicide.
What did the Sandra Birchmore jury say about a deadlock?
According to People magazine reporting, the jury sent a note to U.S. District Judge Denise Casper after a full day of deliberations Monday saying they were deadlocked and that “it will not change any time soon.”
Earlier Monday, the Boston Globe reported, jurors had asked for more time to deliberate before sending that deadlock note. Deliberations began Friday, Nov. 6, after a trial that opened in October in federal court.
Why does the Farwell deadlock matter in this case?
Matthew Farwell, 41, is charged with killing a witness or victim and causing the death of Birchmore’s unborn child. Birchmore was 23 and pregnant when she was found dead in her Canton, Mass., apartment, sitting on the floor with a luggage strap around her neck tied to a doorknob.
Her death was initially ruled a suicide. Federal prosecutors allege Farwell killed her and staged the scene to appear self-inflicted. Authorities claimed the former Stoughton police officer had a years-long relationship with Birchmore that began when she was 15, and that he “used his authority and access as a police officer to groom and sexually abuse Birchmore, including while he was on duty.”
Farwell denied the charges. His attorney maintains Birchmore died by suicide. The standoff is a major development in BlasterPost’s True Crime & Unsolved Mysteries coverage of the case.
What happens after jurors say it will not change soon?
Casper ultimately told the jury to keep deliberating Tuesday, according to NBC 10 and WCVB. Per WCVB, the judge did not provide a so-called “dynamite charge,” which strongly encourages individual jurors to keep an open mind in an effort to reach a unanimous verdict.
That means the panel returned without a formal push toward compromise, even after signaling that positions looked entrenched. Whether further notes follow will shape the next chapter of the high-profile federal trial.