Bizarre News & Florida Man · Wayne Calder · 20 November 2026

Peanut butter revenge: Florida man arrested over letter

Peanut butter revenge: Florida man arrested over letter

A Plantation, Florida, man was arrested after police say he mailed a peanut butter-smeared greeting card to a woman with a life-threatening peanut allergy—an alleged peanut butter revenge Florida plot tied to a bitter divorce. Joseph Gerard Cancellare Jr., 68, faces aggravated battery with a deadly weapon and culpable negligence charges.

Key Takeaways

What happened in the peanut butter revenge Florida case?

On Aug. 14, 2025, a Plantation resident came home from work and found a greasy blue envelope, according to a Plantation Police Department probable cause affidavit reported by CBS Miami.

Inside was a greeting card with a brown substance spread across it. The woman immediately recognized peanut butter, dropped the envelope, called for help, and washed her hands.

She later developed hives on both arms and a tingling sensation that lasted about six hours, arrest documents say. She told police even touching peanuts or airborne particles can trigger a dangerous reaction.

A Broward County booking report said the mail used the fictitious return name "Goergina Sawals."

Why did police arrest the Florida man?

Investigators say Cancellare knew the woman for more than 20 years and was aware of her potentially deadly allergy from social settings and restaurant precautions.

The affidavit links alleged motive to a contentious divorce between Cancellare and his wife, with the alleged victim a longtime acquaintance rather than his spouse. Witnesses told police he had expressed a desire to harm people connected to the situation.

With help from a U.S. postal inspector, detectives traced two Forever stamps to a self-service kiosk at the Davie Post Office on South University Drive. The stamps were bought Aug. 8, 2025, with a Visa card tied to Cancellare, and the kiosk photographed the purchaser.

The victim and others who knew him identified Cancellare in that photo. Police say he drove to a post office in another city and wore sunglasses in an apparent attempt to hide his identity.

What charges does he face and when was he booked?

Plantation police arrested Cancellare at his home on Nov. 13, 2026—more than a year after the mailing. He was taken to HCA Florida Westside Hospital for medical clearance, then booked into the Broward Sheriff's Office main jail.

He faces one count of aggravated battery with a deadly weapon and one count of culpable negligence exposing another person to harm. Detectives concluded he allegedly intended serious injury or death by exposing her to the allergen.

Plantation police said the case shows actions meant to harm others can have life-threatening consequences. More oddities from the Sunshine State live in our Bizarre News & Florida Man hub.

How did investigators connect the letter to him?

A 15-digit code on the Forever stamps identified the kiosk transaction. Those stamps were processed through a Miami postal facility on Aug. 13, 2025—one day before the envelope turned up.

Medical records and a 2017 police report documenting the woman's allergy supported the investigation into 2026, according to CBS Miami's review of the affidavit.

← Open in blast feed