Patrice Evra says Luke Shaw's Man Utd time is over after Hull loss
Former Manchester United defender Patrice Evra says Luke Shaw's time at Old Trafford has gone after United's poor 2-0 opening-day defeat to Hull City. The ex-left-back urged Michael Carrick to sign a replacement left-back urgently, naming Newcastle's Lewis Hall as his ideal £70million target before deadline day.
Manchester United's season opener brought a shock loss to newly promoted Hull City, and the backlash landed quickly on long-serving left-back Luke Shaw. Speaking on his Kick Stream, Evra delivered one of the sharpest assessments yet of Shaw's role in the defeat and what United must do next.
For more on how data and scouting reshape modern squad decisions, see our Future Tech & AI Wonders coverage.
Key Takeaways
- Patrice Evra says Luke Shaw's "time has gone" at Manchester United after the Hull City defeat.
- Evra claims Shaw remains "traumatised" by past injuries and will not go 100% into every challenge.
- The former United left-back urged Michael Carrick to sign a new left-back before the transfer deadline.
- Lewis Hall, valued at around £70million, is Evra's preferred target, though Newcastle are expected to keep him.
- Shaw played all 38 Premier League games last season but has less than 12 months left on his contract.
Why does Patrice Evra think Luke Shaw's time at Man Utd is over?
Evra called United's performance against Hull "one of the worst starts" he had ever seen from the club. He singled out the volume of back passes in the game and Shaw's display as especially disappointing.
The Frenchman said Shaw had suffered injuries that "killed his football career" during his long United career. When Evra speaks to Shaw privately, he said the defender is still traumatised by those setbacks and would not commit fully to every challenge.
"Man United fans want to hear my opinion, and I think [Luke Shaw's] time has gone," Evra said. He added that Shaw might produce a fine performance in the next match, but consistency across a full season is what matters.
Who does Evra want Manchester United to sign at left-back?
Evra argued United need another left-back before the window closes, insisting Patrick Dorgu "is not a left-back, he's a left-winger." His preferred solution is Newcastle United's Lewis Hall, whom Metro valued at £70million.
Evra praised Hall's reliability, saying he offers 90 minutes guaranteed—even citing a penalty he gave away against Liverpool as acceptable if the player shows up every week. United have been linked with Hall, though the BBC and multiple reports suggest he is expected to remain at Newcastle.
Barcelona defender Alejandro Balde has also been linked with a move to Old Trafford before deadline day, according to the Daily Star.
What does Luke Shaw's recent form say about his future?
At 31, Shaw is closing in on 326 United appearances and has less than 12 months remaining on his contract. He started all 38 Premier League matches in 2025-26, his busiest season in four years, yet was controversially omitted from Thomas Tuchel's England squad for the World Cup.
Evra set a blunt benchmark: if Shaw cannot deliver 35 consecutive games, United supporters will not accept sporadic good displays mixed with poor ones. Shaw has been United's first-choice left-back for 12 years, but Evra believes Carrick's side faces a punishing season unless recruitment addresses the position.
Michael Carrick, appointed permanent manager after guiding United to Champions League qualification as interim boss, spent the summer strengthening midfield with Youri Tielemans, Andrey Santos, and Carlos Baleba. Evra's comments suggest the left-back debate may define the closing days of the transfer window.