True Crime & Unsolved Mysteries · Nora Whitfield · 21 November 2026

Pammy Maye sentenced to 29 years to life for boy's murder

Pammy Maye sentenced to 29 years to life for boy's murder

Pammy Maye was sentenced to 29 years to life in prison in Columbus, Ohio, after jurors found her guilty in the February 2024 killing of 5-year-old Darnell Taylor. At her Nov. 19 sentencing she lashed out at her lawyer, was briefly removed from court, then later said she was selfish and called the boy a perfect child.

Key Takeaways

What sentence did Pammy Maye receive?

Judge Mark Serrott sentenced Pammy Maye, 51, to 29 years to life in prison on Nov. 19, 2026. According to Court TV, Serrott said he was "haunted" by a photo of Darnell after the boy's death.

The sentence followed a jury verdict finding Maye guilty on all counts of aggravated murder, abuse of a corpse, and tampering with evidence, WSYX reported. She will be eligible for parole when she is 80.

What happened to Darnell Taylor?

Authorities said that in February 2024, Maye suffocated Darnell while he was in her care, then stuffed his body in a storm drain. Prosecutors told jurors she had been upset with the child for eating peanut butter and crackers in his room in the hours before she killed him with a plastic bag.

Maye and her husband had taken custody of Darnell in May 2023. After the killing, she admitted leaving his body in a sewer in a neighborhood where her parents once lived, then returned home and confessed to her husband, who called 911. She later left for Cleveland, prompting a statewide Amber Alert. Officers found her there walking in a nightgown.

Why was Pammy Maye removed from court?

As Serrott warned the courtroom to keep order, Maye stood and shouted at her attorney, Samuel Shamansky: "You are the Antichrist! Yes, you are!" Deputies held her in her chair. She kept yelling that she did not want his help, and she was removed.

Minutes later she returned. Shamansky said he was withdrawing because she no longer wanted his help. Maye claimed he had acted like a prosecutor and that footage about her was edited. Serrott told her he had seen Shamansky fight hard for her defense and urged her to keep him; Shamansky remained at counsel table.

Maye then spoke about "God's wrath" and claimed she had been "possessed by demons" before Jesus visited her a month earlier. During victim impact statements from Darnell's family, she cried. Given another chance to speak, she said: "I was very selfish. He was a loving child. He was a perfect child."

At trial, Shamansky conceded that Maye killed Darnell but argued she was severely mentally ill and not criminally responsible. For more coverage of cases like this, visit our True Crime & Unsolved Mysteries hub.

← Open in blast feed