Streaming & TV Alerts · Avery Quinn · 6 November 2026

Mistletoe Murders season 3: romance, secrets and twists

Mistletoe Murders season 3: romance, secrets and twists

Mistletoe Murders season 3 premiered November 5 on Hallmark Channel, picking up after Emily Lane (Sarah Drew) opened her door to shady ex Aaron — right after her first kiss with Detective Sam Wilner (Peter Mooney). Stars and creators tease juicy romance twists, CIA flashbacks, and a looming Agency call that could end Emily's Fletcher's Grove life.

Key Takeaways

Hallmark's cozy crime hit is back with higher stakes. For more streaming premieres and TV alerts, browse our Streaming & TV Alerts hub.

What happens in Mistletoe Murders season 3?

According to an exclusive TV Insider set visit, the season opens on last November's cliffhanger. Christmas shop owner Emily answered the doorbell and found Aaron — the ex tied to criminal hacker group Chimera — after finally telling Sam about her past as Grace Barlow and sharing that first kiss.

"All of a sudden, there's a danger zone right at her front door," Drew said. "This really spins Emily's life into a whole new place." She added that even after promising Sam "no more secrets," another secret remains, with "twists and turns in the romance that are very juicy."

Creator and showrunner Ken Cuperus, adapting his Audible series with EP Melanson, mapped a five-season plan. Season 1 introduced a mysterious newcomer; Season 2 rebuilt trust and backstory. Season 3, he said, tears that down as Emily realizes she must return to the Agency and give up her life in town — and face what that does to her bond with Sam.

Viewers learn by the end of Episode 1 that Emily can wrap up her Fletcher's Grove holidays before she is due to move away and start a new life. Flashbacks will cover her Chimera days, "a bit more CIA Grace," and insight into the Season 1 explosion. Cuperus confirmed she left prison after taking an offer to help find Aaron.

How does the Emily and Sam romance change this season?

Mooney said Sam's "spidey sense" alarms go off, yet he tries to trust that Emily has shared what she can — including professional secrets she cannot fully open up about. Both actors stress a peer dynamic, not a damsel-and-rescuer trope: Sam trusts she can handle herself.

In a Parade interview carried by Yahoo, Mooney joked their Zoom chemistry was "borderline alarming." Drew framed Season 2 as the "will they?" chapter and Season 3 as "how will they?" — real relationship work. "Their dates are crime scenes!" she quipped of their flirtatious sleuthing.

Along the case load: guest turns from Catherine Bell (a Season 3 opener prime suspect, per Parade) and Holly Robinson Peete, plus a Christmas Chairman tragedy and a local who thinks they are Santa.

Where can you watch Mistletoe Murders season 3?

New episodes air Thursdays at 8 p.m. ET through December 10, except November 26 at 10 p.m. ET. Each episode streams on Hallmark+ the day after its Hallmark Channel premiere. Seasons 1 and 2 recently landed on Netflix and quickly climbed the most-watched lists, per Parade.

← Open in blast feed