Michaella Love Blind reunion clash with Matt, explained
At the Love Is Blind Season 11 reunion, Michaella Giorgio and Boston beekeeper Matt Waldrip clashed over a secret post-show romance. He said he fell in love with her; she called that an exaggeration and said she told him she loved him while on mushrooms. Both later unpacked the fight. The Michaella Love Blind drama is still buzzing across celebrity breaking news.
Key Takeaways
- Matt told Michaella he fell in love with her after the experiment; she called that an exaggeration.
- She reached out about six months after filming, following her split from Rob.
- Matt says they dated from around September to late November; Michaella disputes how serious it was.
- Her mushrooms comment about saying she loved him was the most hurtful line for Matt.
- Neither wants to rekindle the romance after the reunion.
What sparked the Michaella and Matt reunion clash?
On the Season 11 reunion stage, Matt dropped a bombshell: “Michaella and I did have a relationship after the experiment ended. Ultimately, I did fall in love with you.” Michaella pushed back, calling his framing “an exaggeration of our relationship.”
Emotions ran hot in real time. In a later Netflix Tudum interview, Matt said they walked away with “two different memories” of the same chapter.
Separately, Michaella also tripped over her dress and fell onstage while rushing to comfort castmate Sarah Williams, then laughed it off with “All to hug you!”
Did Michaella and Matt really date after the pods?
Yes — at least according to Matt. Michaella reached out roughly six months after filming wrapped, drawn to him as “the exact opposite of Rob” after her engagement ended. Matt says they dated from around September to late November.
Michaella frames it more like a rebound that crossed a line. “If I could go back and change it, I would’ve stayed friends with him,” she said. She also rejected the idea they were in love, casting what he described as meeting families as a drop-off at his mom’s house.
Matt insists the connection was romantic, not casual, and blames distance — about two and a half hours in Boston traffic — plus his responsibilities as a single father for the split. He says both cried when it ended, and credits her for being willing to try.
How did Matt take the mushrooms comment?
One of the sharpest reunion moments came when Michaella claimed she was on mushrooms when she told Matt she loved him. Matt told Tudum that was “probably the most hurtful thing she said,” adding he has “no recollection of that” and has “never done shrooms.”
To him, the line felt like she was “minimizing or dismissing” feelings she had once communicated as very real.
Do Matt and Michaella want to get back together?
No. Matt says there has been no contact since the reunion and he would not have a desire to reconnect, though he’d be cordial if they crossed paths. Onstage, Michaella shut down his offer of support with a blunt “I need nothing.”
Matt even joked he was glad he “didn’t bring the honey” as a gift. He’s focusing on his beehives and his son; Michaella says she’s excited to start dating again and ready to be a great partner.