Jury deadlocked in Matthew Farwell's Birchmore death trial
A federal jury says it is deadlocked in Matthew Farwell's trial over the death of Sandra Birchmore after more than 10 hours of deliberations. Jurors were sent home Monday and told to return Tuesday as Chief U.S. District Judge Denise Casper weighs next steps.
Key Takeaways
- Jurors told the court they are in a deadlock that "looks like will not change anytime soon."
- Matthew Farwell, a former Stoughton police detective, faces two federal charges and automatic life in prison if convicted.
- Prosecutors allege he killed pregnant Sandra Birchmore in 2021 and staged a suicide; he pleaded not guilty.
- The panel returns Tuesday; if deadlock persists, the judge could issue further instructions or declare a mistrial.
What did the jury tell the court?
The panel of eight men and four women began deliberating Friday afternoon after closing arguments in U.S. District Court in Boston. By Monday, after about 10 and a half hours, jurors sent Judge Casper a note saying they were deadlocked and that the impasse looked unlikely to change soon.
Casper dismissed them just before 4:30 p.m. and directed them to come back Tuesday. She told lawyers she does not think deliberations have gone on too long yet. Defense attorneys indicated they will ask for specific instructions in the morning; the judge said she was inclined to bring jurors back without further guidance first.
If the jury still cannot agree, Casper could instruct them on their duty to decide the case. A continued deadlock could end in a mistrial, leaving prosecutors to decide whether to retry Farwell, according to The Boston Globe.
What is Matthew Farwell accused of?
Farwell, 41, faces two federal counts: killing a witness or victim, and a charge tied to the death of Birchmore's unborn child. Prosecutors say he killed Birchmore, 23, on Feb. 1, 2021, during a visit to her Canton apartment to stop information about his alleged federal crimes from reaching law enforcement. She was pregnant and due in September 2021.
Birchmore was found dead on Feb. 4, 2021, after missing work as a school aide. Federal prosecutors argue Farwell strangled her and staged the scene as a suicide. Farwell pleaded not guilty and argues she killed herself, citing a prior suicide attempt, mental-health history, and defense experts who disputed strangulation findings.
Surveillance video showed Farwell entering her building in a hoodie and face mask that night. Digital evidence put Birchmore's phone's last movement minutes before he was seen leaving, witnesses testified. The case is closely watched in true crime and unsolved mysteries coverage because state authorities initially treated the death as a suicide before the FBI pursued a homicide case.
Why does this deadlock matter?
The jury heard just over three weeks of testimony after being empaneled on Oct. 9, covering alleged child sexual abuse, conflicting medical opinions, and how Birchmore died. Friends and family long insisted she did not kill herself and pressed investigators to scrutinize Farwell.
A conviction would mean life in prison. A mistrial would reopen the path to a retrial decision and prolong a case that already spanned years between Birchmore's death and federal charges. All eyes turn to Tuesday's deliberations for the next signal on whether this jury can break its deadlock.