Martin McDonagh's Wild Horse Nine sparks Oscar buzz
Martin McDonagh's new black comedy Wild Horse Nine, starring John Malkovich and Sam Rockwell as CIA agents vacationing on Easter Island just before Chile's 1973 coup, is drawing strong critical praise and early Best Actor Oscar buzz for Malkovich as the film hits theaters. Major reviews frame the Searchlight release as another lethal mix of banter and melancholy from the Irish writer-director.
Key Takeaways
- The Wall Street Journal calls Malkovich's turn the heart of a "surprisingly emotional tour de force" from Martin McDonagh.
- Slate's Dana Stevens argues Malkovich should finally win Best Actor for the role.
- The New York Times praises the cast but says grim history sits uneasily with McDonagh's irony.
- Set in 1973, CIA partners Chris and Lee travel from Santiago to Rapa Nui (Easter Island).
- Rated R, the film runs about 1 hour 58 minutes and is now in theaters.
What is Wild Horse Nine about?
Per Slate and The New York Times, Wild Horse Nine follows CIA agents Chris Carlisle (John Malkovich) and Lee Chesterfield (Sam Rockwell) in 1973 as a U.S.-backed overthrow of Chilean president Salvador Allende nears. Stationed in Santiago, they holiday on Easter Island—Rapa Nui—among the Moai statues.
Chris has terminal cancer and short-term memory loss, which loosens his tongue about the coup. They meet Chilean student activists Monica (Mariana di Girolamo) and Alicia (Ailín Salas). Steve Buscemi plays bureau chief MJ; Parker Posey appears as Lee's wife, Marge.
Why are critics excited about Martin McDonagh's latest?
The Wall Street Journal billed the film a "black-comic beauty," with Kyle Smith writing that Malkovich's "wickedly entertaining, cynical yet soulful performance is the heart of a surprisingly emotional tour de force from Mr. McDonagh."
Slate links the story to In Bruges and The Banshees of Inisherin—two men in a dangerous trade, stuck somewhere picturesque, awaiting violence—while Rockwell, in his third McDonagh film, delivers the director's rhythmic dialogue. For more awards-season coverage, see our Celebrity Breaking News hub.
The New York Times' Manohla Dargis calls it a "laugh- and blood-flecked romp" with visual luster, chewy writing, and Carter Burwell's score, yet finds the real past of Vietnam, Cuba, and Congo weighs too heavily for McDonagh's detached style.
Could John Malkovich finally win an Oscar?
Slate reports Malkovich is the current Best Actor favorite in awards predictions and notes he has been nominated twice without winning. Stevens calls him a revelation as a fragile, guilty man facing mortality after a career propping up dictators and engineering assassinations.
Dargis likewise finds him "mesmerizing," a virtuoso of tonal shifts even when the story turns more serious. That WSJ-to-Slate consensus makes Malkovich the clear awards-season center of the film.
How does Wild Horse Nine fit McDonagh's career?
Critics map the movie to In Bruges' hit-men-on-holiday setup and Banshees' island male friendship. Slate adds that, like Three Billboards, it risks using others' tragedies as backdrop—but argues the film is largely about American imperialism, so the barbs hit the right targets.
Whether viewers see a black-comic beauty or a strained historical joke, Martin McDonagh's latest puts Malkovich and Rockwell front and center as the R-rated, nearly two-hour spy tragicomedy opens wide.