Lori Vallow asks Idaho Supreme Court for a new trial
Lori Vallow Daybell asked the Idaho Supreme Court on Monday to overturn her 2023 murder convictions and grant a new trial, arguing that removing her chosen attorney violated her Sixth Amendment right to counsel of choice. Prosecutors said the judge correctly found a conflict of interest. A ruling is pending.
The high-stakes appeal focuses on whether the trial court wrongly disqualified attorney Mark Means while Lori Vallow was still deemed incompetent to stand trial. Defense counsel called the removal unconstitutional; the Idaho Attorney General's Office said the judge faced an "incredibly difficult" ethical bind and acted properly. For more court and case tracking, see our Fintech & Crypto Alerts hub.
Key Takeaways
- Lori Vallow seeks to toss her Idaho murder and conspiracy convictions and win a new trial.
- Her appeal centers on Sixth Amendment claims over the disqualification of Mark Means.
- Prosecutors argue Means had a real conflict tied to Chad Daybell and confidential dealings.
- The Idaho Supreme Court heard arguments Nov. 2, 2026, and will rule later.
- JJ Vallow's grandfather, Larry Woodcock, said he is unsurprised by the bid.
What did Lori Vallow's lawyers argue before the court?
According to KSL reporting, attorney Craig Durham told justices that Means's removal deprived Lori Vallow of counsel of her choice. He called it a "flawed process that led to a flawed result," saying the Sixth Amendment requires an actual conflict of interest—not an assumed one—before stripping a paying defendant of her chosen advocate.
Durham said there was no evidence Chad Daybell shared confidential information with Means, and that Chad had waived any potential conflict. Lori Vallow could not waive then because she had been found incompetent. He also argued she lacked a voice in the removal hearing and that the judge could have appointed conflict counsel instead.
Other appeal claims—pretrial counsel gaps, presence at hearings while incompetent, Arizona uncharged-act evidence, and speedy-trial dismissal—were largely not argued in depth Monday.
How did prosecutors defend the attorney's removal?
Assistant attorney general Jeff Nye said the judge was right to disqualify Means. Prosecutors cited Means publicly claiming he represented Chad Daybell, Chad's first call to Means when a warrant led to the children's bodies, and a jail call in which Chad said they consolidated to one attorney "for reasons of confidentiality."
Nye also noted Chad paid Lori Vallow's legal fees and that Means filed sworn statements from her while the case was on hold for incompetency. A second-attorney workaround failed when Means kept filing inappropriate documents, Nye said. "Nothing that happened here is normal, but that doesn't mean there was error in any of it," he argued.
What happens next—and why does the family care?
Lori Vallow was convicted in 2023 of murdering her children, 7-year-old JJ Vallow and 16-year-old Tylee Ryan, conspiring to kill Tammy Daybell, and grand theft of Social Security benefits, drawing five life sentences. In 2025 she received two more consecutive life terms after an Arizona conspiracy conviction involving Charles Vallow's killing and a related shooting attempt. Chad Daybell was convicted in 2024 and sentenced to death.
Justice Cynthia Meyer asked whether reversing the conviction could put the death penalty back on the table. Durham said Lori Vallow knows that risk and still wants to proceed. JJ's grandfather Larry Woodcock told Idaho News he was "absolutely not surprised," warning she should be careful what she asks for. The Idaho Supreme Court will issue a decision at a later date.