True Crime & Unsolved Mysteries · Marcus Cole · 12 November 2026

Lindsay Clancy planning appeal after judge denies motion

Lindsay Clancy planning appeal after judge denies motion

Lindsay Clancy planning appeal of a Massachusetts judge's Nov. 9 denial of her motion to dismiss murder charges on double jeopardy grounds. Judge William Sullivan found a September mistrial was justified by jury deadlock, so a retrial would not violate her rights, her attorney told People.

Key Takeaways

Why was Lindsay Clancy's dismissal motion denied?

Sullivan rejected the defense claim that retrying Clancy would place her in double jeopardy after the September mistrial. In his order, he wrote that there was a "manifest necessity for a mistrial based on the jury's deadlock," so a new trial on the murder indictments would not violate her rights. He also defended declaring the mistrial and declining to dismiss or question the lone holdout juror.

What did Clancy's lawyers say about an appeal?

Shortly after the Nov. 9 ruling, constitutional lawyer Martin Weinberg told People: "We have in Massachusetts one of the most respected state supreme courts. We will be deciding on the timing of an appeal in the very near future." The planned challenge may give prosecutors more time before announcing next steps.

What happens next in the Lindsay Clancy case?

Sullivan's denial means prosecutors will likely need to say how they will proceed. The Plymouth County District Attorney's Office has not announced whether it will retry Clancy or seek a plea deal. Clancy, a former nurse, is charged with killing her three young children. The defense has said she was experiencing postpartum psychosis.

She remains at Tewksbury Hospital. Readers following high-profile cases can find more coverage in BlasterPost's true crime and unsolved mysteries section.

What else is pending for Clancy?

Clancy also faces a civil medical malpractice suit. Attorney Andrew Meyer previously told People the lawsuit alleges her providers responded to psychiatric struggles by changing and increasing her medication while failing to recognize the actual diagnosis and problems she was having.

Meyer argues those alleged failures contributed to the events of Jan. 24, 2023, when Clancy asked her husband Patrick to pick up dinner. He returned about 25 minutes later, found she had jumped from a second-story window, and then discovered Cora, 5, Dawson, 3, and 8-month-old Callan had been strangled with exercise bands. The two oldest were pronounced dead soon after arriving at the hospital, and Callan died a few days later.

← Open in blast feed