True Crime & Unsolved Mysteries · Diana Graves · 8 November 2026

Legal expert: Naresh Bhatt is gambling on his confession

Legal expert: Naresh Bhatt is gambling on his confession

A legal expert says Naresh Bhatt is gambling that jurors will acquit him of murder after he admitted on the stand to dismembering and hiding his wife's body while claiming she died by suicide. Criminal defense attorney Frank Salvato told WUSA9 the defense is betting on reasonable doubt for the killing itself.

Key Takeaways

What did Naresh Bhatt tell the jury?

On the stand Thursday in Manassas, Virginia, Naresh Bhatt told jurors his wife, Mamta Kafle Bhatt, died by suicide. He also confessed that he dismembered her body and tried to hide it, admitting he used a saw to cut up her remains.

Bhatt said he found her unconscious at the foot of their bed, surrounded by vomit, blood, and an open insecticide packet on the night she went missing. Mamta Kafle Bhatt, a young mother and nurse, vanished more than two years ago from their Manassas Park home. Police arrested Naresh Bhatt three weeks later.

He faces first-degree murder plus concealment and defilement of a dead body charges. For more coverage in this category, see BlasterPost's True Crime & Unsolved Mysteries hub.

Why does a legal expert say Naresh Bhatt is gambling?

WUSA9's Katie Lusso interviewed criminal defense attorney Frank Salvato after the bombshell testimony. Salvato said Bhatt and the defense have effectively conceded guilt on concealment and defilement. "They are gambling" that the jury will find him not guilty of the murder charges, Salvato said, according to WUSA9's report.

In Salvato's view, the strategy is to own the admitted handling of the remains while leaving room for reasonable doubt on who caused the death. He described it as one available defense path: send the lesser, conceded counts to the jury and gamble on the murder counts.

Salvato also noted that after roughly two years of a different account, the late switch may help or hurt. Jurors could accept that he lied earlier but is truthful now, or treat the last-minute change as fatal to his credibility and convict of premeditated murder.

Could the jury still return a second-degree verdict?

On Friday, attorneys met with Judge Kimberly Irving on jury instructions near the end of the trial. The court will offer a waterfall instruction down to second-degree murder, but not to manslaughter.

Salvato explained that a waterfall starts at the most serious charge and steps down if jurors reject higher elements. Under the planned instructions, if jurors find the killing was not premeditated and willful as defined for first-degree murder, they could consider second-degree murder.

Even so, Salvato said he does not see this as a second-degree case. He called it "an all-or-nothing situation"—either acquittal or a first-degree murder conviction—while cautioning that juries can surprise everyone.

When could jurors decide the Naresh Bhatt case?

Salvato told WUSA9 he expects the case to go to the jury as early as Monday, with brief redirect, a few short defense witnesses, possible Commonwealth impeachment witnesses, then closings. He said deliberations on murder may be fairly brief because Bhatt has already conceded the other charges.

He put the chance of a last-second plea deal "next to zero" at this stage. Earlier talks never produced a formal offer, and Salvato suggested any prior deal would likely have hinged on disclosing the location of the remains.

← Open in blast feed