True Crime & Unsolved Mysteries · Marcus Cole · 21 November 2026

Judge denies Murdaugh's bid to dismiss murder indictment

Judge denies Murdaugh's bid to dismiss murder indictment

A South Carolina judge on Friday denied Alex Murdaugh's motion to dismiss the murder indictment charging him in the killings of his wife and son, clearing the way for a 2027 retrial. Judge Debra McCaslin ruled the defense failed to prove intentional misconduct that tainted the grand jury.

Key Takeaways

What did the judge decide on Murdaugh's indictment?

In an 11-page order issued Friday, McCaslin denied the bid to dismiss the original grand jury murder charges. According to ABC News, she concluded Murdaugh had not shown "intentional prosecutorial or investigative misconduct" that compromised the grand jury.

The ruling keeps the case on track for a second trial. Prosecutors had said they were ready to seek fresh indictments in December if the originals were tossed, but that step is no longer required.

For more coverage of high-profile homicide cases, see BlasterPost's True Crime & Unsolved Mysteries hub.

Why did the defense want the original indictments dismissed?

Defense attorneys argued that former State Law Enforcement Division agent David Owen misled the Colleton County grand jury in 2022. They claimed he wrongly said blood spatter was on Murdaugh's shirt and that other guns on the property matched the load used to kill Paul Murdaugh.

At a Nov. 13 hearing, attorney Jim Griffin called for a "reboot" and new charging papers. Owen later acknowledged at the 2023 trial that some of what he told the grand jury about shotgun loads was inaccurate, and that he had not seen a lab report finding no human blood on the shirt until after the indictment.

McCaslin criticized Owen for failing to fully review a key laboratory report before testifying, saying such oversights "undermine public confidence." She still found the failure did not amount to bad-faith misconduct warranting dismissal.

What happens next in the Murdaugh murder case?

Margaret "Maggie" Murdaugh, 52, and Paul Murdaugh, 22, were found shot to death at the family's Colleton County hunting estate on June 7, 2021. A jury convicted Alex Murdaugh in 2023; the state Supreme Court later unanimously overturned those verdicts, citing "shocking jury interference" by the former county clerk of court.

The retrial is scheduled for April 5, 2027, in Sumter County. Lead prosecutor Creighton Waters has pointed to other evidence, including a cellphone video that prosecutors say places Murdaugh with Maggie and Paul minutes before the killings.

Murdaugh remains imprisoned after pleading guilty to separate financial crimes, with a 27-year state sentence and a 40-year federal sentence. He continues to deny killing his wife and son.

← Open in blast feed