Celebrity Breaking News · Jordan Blake · 6 November 2026

Joe Scarborough and Katie Nolan blast Pat McAfee on GameDay

Joe Scarborough and Katie Nolan blast Pat McAfee on GameDay

Joe Scarborough’s Morning Joe blast of Pat McAfee now has company: former ESPN star Katie Nolan accused the College GameDay host of “irresponsible” behavior on her podcast, saying he acts out then expects others to manage his feelings—renewing debate over McAfee’s outsized role.

The criticism from Nolan landed days after Scarborough said he had “had enough” of McAfee “ruining” ESPN’s Saturday college football show, putting the polarizing personality back at the center of sports-media chatter. For more celebrity media fallout, see Celebrity Breaking News.

Key Takeaways

What did Katie Nolan say about Pat McAfee?

On a podcast episode released Wednesday, Nolan—who spent four years at ESPN and later worked at Fox Sports 1 and Apple—targeted McAfee’s public posture. “The guy is winning in every sense of the word, and yet is constantly acting like the world is attacking him baselessly,” she said, according to Yahoo Sports citing Awful Announcing.

“He acts irresponsibly, but then wants everyone to be responsible for his emotional well-being, and to take care of him,” Nolan added. She described herself as sensitive and said she did not handle online meanness well during baseball season, adding that if McAfee had her mentions, he “wouldn’t be able to talk about anything else.”

Why is Joe Scarborough criticizing College GameDay?

On election morning, the Morning Joe panel spent more than two minutes on McAfee. “I’ve just had enough of this Pat McAfee ruining ‘College GameDay,’” Scarborough said, per Deseret News. He said he looks forward to Saturday mornings with the show, then added it feels like McAfee is “melting down.”

Scarborough argued ESPN’s push to give McAfee more time is overshadowing Rece Davis, Nick Saban, Kirk Herbstreit, and Desmond Howard. Geist agreed the vibe shifted after McAfee joined full-time in 2022, calling him the de facto lead of what he still labeled Saturday morning “church” for college football fans.

Scarborough also jabbed at McAfee’s reaction to a University of Utah student video before GameDay’s Oct. 24 Salt Lake City stop, saying the host should not be “yelling at people and being freaked out” over signs or mockery. McAfee later said he felt “uncomfortable” seeing the clip on the school’s official social channels; Utah apologized for missing the mark. He separately said on X that he had received death threats that reached his wife and children.

Did Nolan offer any praise for McAfee?

Yes. Nolan said that when McAfee “adds to a broadcast, he really can,” citing youthful energy in an industry full of “old-guard guys.” Her issue, she said, is needing to perform “without anyone saying anything mean, ever.” She added she does not want to make light of fear, but finds some of the panic “irrational.”

McAfee is scheduled back on College GameDay this Saturday from 9 a.m. to 12 p.m. ET, as the Joe Scarborough and Nolan criticism keeps the spotlight on how much of the show should revolve around him.

← Open in blast feed