Fintech & Crypto Alerts · Cameron Ellis · 5 November 2026

If S&P 500 falls 20%, buy this ETF over Nasdaq 100

If S&P 500 falls 20%, buy this ETF over Nasdaq 100

If the S&P 500 falls 20%, Motley Fool writer Ben Gran says he would buy the Vanguard S&P 500 ETF (VOO)—not chase a Nasdaq 100 rebound. He argues the broader index has historically held up better than tech-heavy peers in bear markets, while offering nearly a century of roughly 10% annualized returns for patient buyers.

Since a record high on Oct. 6, the S&P 500 has slipped about 3% as AI-stock skepticism grew. That mild pullback has investors asking what to do if a full bear market arrives. For more market alerts, see our Fintech & Crypto Alerts hub.

Key Takeaways

Why buy VOO in a crash instead of the Nasdaq 100?

Gran's answer, published via Yahoo Finance, is blunt: if the S&P 500 falls 20%, buy more of it. VOO owns a diversified basket of about 505 large U.S. stocks—AI names such as Nvidia and Alphabet, financials like JPMorgan Chase, and healthcare leaders like Eli Lilly.

That breadth is the point. Nobody knows which mega-caps will win next. Even if an AI boom turns into an AI crash, the overall S&P 500 might fare better than the Nasdaq 100—as it did in 2022.

How has the S&P 500 held up through past crashes?

From 1928 through wars, depressions, and panics, the S&P 500 still delivered about 9.98% annualized returns over 98 years. Single stocks can go to zero. A broad market fund historically has not.

VOO's roughly 14.8% average annual return over about 16 years as an ETF reinforces that long-run case. Buying after a 20% decline, Gran notes, is simply purchasing that engine at a discount. Still, he stresses VOO is not "safe"—it can lose value in a crash or prolonged bear market.

What's weighing on the Nasdaq 100 into Q4?

Separately, the Nasdaq 100 is up about 12.4% year to date even while Nvidia, Microsoft, Amazon, Meta Platforms, Alphabet, and Tesla lag that index—Apple being the Magnificent Seven exception. Yet a Zacks Q4 QQQ roadmap flags sharp AI turbulence: QQQ just suffered its worst three-day decline since Liberation Day, with U.S. tech momentum looking worse than the dot-com bust by one Morgan Stanley reading.

Cited headwinds include inflation and higher rates, AI political pushback, funding and debt fears, plus gravity from profit-taking. Some dip-buyers prefer Vanguard's Mega Cap Growth ETF (MGK) at a 0.05% expense ratio over Invesco QQQ Trust's 0.18%, partly because QQQ excludes NYSE growth names such as Eli Lilly, Visa, and Mastercard.

Is a 20% S&P selloff an automatic buy signal?

Sources do not forecast a crash as certain—only about a 3% retreat so far. The hypothetical is clear: if a 20% drawdown arrives, Gran's pick is VOO, not a frantic Nasdaq 100 chase. Diversification, rock-bottom cost (VOO's expense ratio matches the industry's lowest 0.03% tier among major funds cited), and nearly a century of compounding are the reasons he would buy hand over fist.

← Open in blast feed