Ebenezer first reactions hail Johnny Depp's Scrooge comeback
Early 8216ebenezer8217 first reactions johnny Depp has drawn are largely positive, with film press calling his Scrooge return in Ti West's Ebenezer a wickedly fun holiday treat and strong comeback vehicle. Reviews praise gothic style and emotional resonance, while dissenters say the Christmas Carol remake feels superfluous or forgettable ahead of its Nov. 13 theatrical release.
Key Takeaways
- First reactions to Ebenezer are largely positive, framing Johnny Depp's Scrooge as a Hollywood comeback.
- Supporters credit Ti West's gothic visuals and Depp's mix of charm and gravitas.
- Critics who passed call the film forgettable, boring, or "utterly superfluous."
- Paramount opens the Dickens reimagining in theaters on Nov. 13, 2026.
What are critics saying about Ebenezer so far?
According to Variety, the film has premiered and early press notes are mostly upbeat. UK critic Phil Roberts called it a "bold spin on Dickens' classic" and said Depp is "magnetic throughout Scrooge's soft redemption arc," arguing the finale delivers more emotional resonance than earlier versions.
Tom Chatalbash of FilmSpeak labeled it a "wickedly fun holiday treat and strong comeback vehicle for its star," praising Depp as a "fiendish delight as Scrooge." Critics Choice members Clarence Moye and Tony Mosello also chimed in, with Moye ranking Depp among the best modern Scrooges beside George C. Scott and Mosello highlighting a "fun, quirky, and energetic" lead turn plus West's gothic horror vibes.
Is every first reaction a rave?
No. Ren Vieira wrote that Ebenezer hits the expected Christmas Carol beats but offers nothing distinct, calling Depp's turn "cooky Scrooge" and "old tricks" despite strong design work. MaryAnn Johanson kept it blunt: "Utterly superfluous."
Robert Ortiz said the film is "fine," technically solid, and that Depp looks and acts the part, yet judged it forgettable and boring if you already know the story. That split is why the premiere chatter matters for anyone tracking holiday tentpoles on our Streaming & TV Alerts desk.
Why does Ebenezer matter for Johnny Depp's comeback?
Variety notes Ebenezer is Depp's first Hollywood studio film since his highly publicized 2022 trial against Amber Heard. The project was aimed as a major return for the Edward Scissorhands star, and several early notices explicitly sell it as a comeback vehicle.
Ti West directs the reimagining of A Christmas Carol, billed as "The name you know, the story you don't." The ensemble includes Rupert Grint, Andrea Riseborough, Sam Claflin, Daisy Ridley, Arthur Conti, Ellie Bamber, Henry Lloyd-Hughes, Charlie Murphy, Tramell Tillman, and Ian McKellen.
Paramount will release Ebenezer in theaters on Nov. 13, putting Depp's first Hollywood studio film since 2022 in front of general audiences after a premiere that drew largely positive, if not unanimous, first reactions from the film press.