Fintech & Crypto Alerts · Quinn Barrett · 12 November 2026

DC fights Seat Geek over secondhand ticket resale caps

DC fights Seat Geek over secondhand ticket resale caps

Washington, D.C., is urging a federal judge to reject a lawsuit by Seat Geek, Vivid Seats, TickPick, and Gametime that seeks to block the city's RESALE Act before it takes effect Jan. 1, 2027. The law caps secondhand markups at 10% above face value and requires original-price disclosure.

Key Takeaways

The fight lands squarely in Fintech & Crypto Alerts territory: regulated marketplaces, fee transparency, and who controls secondary pricing for live events.

What does the RESALE Act require of ticket platforms?

Passed unanimously by the D.C. Council, the Restricting Egregious Scalping Against Live Entertainment Act is billed as among the nation's toughest anti-scalping rules. Resellers cannot charge more than 10% above the original purchase price, including fees and taxes. Marketplaces may add a separate service fee of up to 10% of that original price.

The law also bans speculative "ghost" tickets sold before official on-sale, requires disclosure of the original cost, and forces vendors who resell more than 50 tickets a year to register for a D.C. business license. It is scheduled to take effect Jan. 1, 2027.

Why is Seat Geek challenging the DC law?

Ticket Policy Forum, a trade group for third-party resellers, sued last month on behalf of Seat Geek, Vivid Seats, Gametime, and TickPick. The complaint asks a federal court to declare the law unconstitutional and grant a preliminary injunction pausing enforcement.

Plaintiffs argue D.C. cannot regulate sales between out-of-state parties—said to be 85-90% of their D.C. show volume—and that the 110% price ceiling is too low for a reasonable return. They also claim forcing disclosure of original prices is compelled speech under the First Amendment. Forum executive director Brian Berry warned the law would push sales "into the shadows" and raise fraud risk.

According to The 51st, D.C. Attorney General attorneys countered that platforms are hiding "inside a Trojan Horse of constitutional claims." Pollstar reported a 60-page District response saying plaintiffs "dressed their policy objections up in constitutional garb."

The platforms further object that the act exempts primary sellers from matching caps. Ward 6 councilmember Charles Allen, who introduced the bill, said resellers are trying to preserve "enormous profits." Live Nation's Dan Wall called the Forum an "astroturf group" for predatory resellers, while I.M.P. communications director Audrey Fix Schaefer noted Ticketmaster's own resale must follow the same rules.

What happens next in the federal case?

U.S. District Judge Carl Nichols is set to hear the injunction request on Nov. 19. Ticket Policy Forum wants a ruling by Dec. 10 to allow an appeal before the new year if needed. D.C. says compliance costs in one city do not outweigh the public interest in consumer protections, and private consumer claims could still proceed even if enforcement were paused.

Venue operators including Black Cat backed the law, arguing resale markups divert money from artists and local businesses. Similar bills have advanced or been floated in Massachusetts, Vermont, California, and New York, but D.C. is the first jurisdiction Ticket Policy Forum has taken to court. A separate reseller suit challenges only the price cap.

← Open in blast feed