True Crime & Unsolved Mysteries · Nora Whitfield · 21 November 2026

Chelsea Leeds penalty handball: was Rogers call correct?

Chelsea Leeds penalty handball: was Rogers call correct?

Yes — under current Premier League handball law, the Chelsea Leeds penalty handball against Morgan Rogers was a justifiable call. Referee Michael Oliver awarded it after Rogers raised his arm into Jayden Bogle's shot, a move treated as a deliberate act; VAR did not overturn it despite harsh criticism.

Key Takeaways

Why was the Chelsea Leeds penalty handball given?

Saturday's clash flipped when Leeds went ahead from the spot. Rogers turned away with folded arms raised as Bogle shot from distance. BBC Sport's Dale Johnson explained two factors that mattered: the ball's travel distance gave Rogers time to adjust, and his arm rose into the ball's flight.

Had the arm stayed lower at midriff level, there would have been no offence. Because the raised arm deflected the ball away, officials treated it as a deliberate act — which, under the Premier League's interpretation, trumps other considerations. VAR Michael Salisbury did not intervene to overturn Oliver's call.

Was there a case not to award it?

The only plausible VAR debate, per the BBC, was whether contact was too high on the arm, outside the punishable "red zone." It looked close but still inside that zone. Face-protection arguments usually apply when hands go to the face, not when an arm is used as a barrier.

A similar precedent last season saw James Tarkowski penalised for leaning into a Leeds shot even with his arm tucked — intent via body movement was enough. Rogers raising his arm sat in the same category of justifiable penalty.

What did Alonso and the pundits say?

Chelsea boss Xabi Alonso told Sky Sports the call was "quite a harsh decision" and that he would not have given a penalty. He later said he did not agree with the referee or VAR, arguing Leeds may not have got the award had it not been given on the field. Still, he admitted Chelsea lost momentum after Leeds equalised and were in a "fragile moment" mentally.

Match of the Day's Alan Shearer said he did not agree with Oliver's award and argued officials "can't use common sense," claiming Rogers was protecting his face rather than stopping the ball. Nedum Onuoha labelled it "a terrible decision." Shearer also said Chelsea were deservedly beaten by a stronger Leeds side.

Emmanuel Emegha had put the hosts ahead before Noah Okafor levelled; after Calvert-Lewin's penalty, Okafor and Brenden Aaronson sealed the rout. For more disputed calls and lingering sports controversies, explore our True Crime & Unsolved Mysteries hub.

← Open in blast feed