Casey Schmitt ends a 40-game walk drought but one red flag remains
San Francisco Giants infielder Casey Schmitt ended a 40-game, 173 plate-appearance walk drought on July 9, 2026—the longest by a Giants player since Hal Lanier in 1964. His league-low 2.0% walk rate remains the red flag chasing an otherwise real breakout season.
Key Takeaways
- Casey Schmitt worked a four-pitch walk against Ryan Feltner on July 9, ending a streak dating to May 24.
- The drought spanned 40 games and 173 plate appearances, the Giants' longest walk-less run since 1964.
- Schmitt owns a 2.0% walk rate in 2026, the lowest among qualified MLB hitters despite strong offensive numbers.
- His 37.5% chase rate invites pitchers to pitch outside the zone until he proves more plate discipline.
- Teammate Luis Arraez earned 2026 All-Star honors while Schmitt's contact-heavy approach keeps drawing scrutiny.
Why did Casey Schmitt go 40 games without a walk?
Casey Schmitt had not drawn a free pass since May 24 against the Chicago White Sox when he faced Colorado Rockies starter Ryan Feltner on July 9. The drought ended in the fifth inning of San Francisco's 8-2 win at Oracle Park, when Schmitt took four pitches for a walk in his third at-bat.
He homered on the second pitch he saw and lined out earlier that night—typical of a swing-first approach defining his 2026 season. Around the Foghorn noted he had been in a two-week slump before that breakout performance.
McCovey Chronicles tied the streak to a team-wide swing-first mentality under hitting coach Hunter Mense. Schmitt joked about the drought in a postgame NBC Sports Bay Area interview, saying he expected questions about at-bats until his next walk rather than his seven first-inning home runs.
How historic was Casey Schmitt's walk drought?
Schmitt's 173 plate appearances without a walk mark the longest span by any Giants player since Hal Lanier went 279 without one in 1964, according to McCovey Chronicles.
In the Oracle Park era, only Shawon Dunston endured a longer walk-less stretch, going 246 plate appearances across 105 games from May 2001 to July 2002. Schmitt has drawn just eight walks in 85 games for a 2.0% walk rate—the lowest in the majors among qualified hitters.
Can Casey Schmitt keep hitting without drawing walks?
So far, yes. Schmitt's breakout has been one of the few bright spots on a struggling Giants club, even as plate discipline raises sustainability questions. He carries a 35.7% career chase rate versus a 28.6% MLB average, and his 37.5% mark in 2026 ranks in the 11th percentile league-wide.
Pitchers have less incentive to throw strikes to a hitter who rarely walks, which could force Schmitt to expand the zone. In college and the minors he walked roughly 8.5% of the time, suggesting the current approach may reflect pressure to hit his way into a permanent role.
Yet his contact quality has been undeniable. McCovey Chronicles noted he swings more than most hitters while still making contact at elite rates, and his batted-ball results back up the production—for now.
What does this mean for the Giants as All-Star week arrives?
While Schmitt's walk woes dominate talk, teammate Luis Arraez heads to Philadelphia for the July 14 All-Star Game after transforming his defense at second base under Ron Washington. MLB.com reported Arraez entered the break tied for second among second basemen in Fielding Run Value and in Gold Glove contention alongside a .326 average.
Both hitters reflect Hunter Mense's contact-forward philosophy, but only Arraez pairs elite on-base skills with All-Star recognition. Schmitt's defensive versatility remains valuable regardless of walks, as Around the Foghorn emphasized—yet his free-pass drought is the stat Giants analysts cannot ignore.
For more breakout athlete stories, follow our Celebrity Breaking News coverage.