Andrew Garfield may return in two MCU projects after Secret Wars
Andrew Garfield and Tobey Maguire fans could see both Spider-Men again well beyond Avengers: Secret Wars. Insider MyTimeToShineHello claims Marvel already plans two additional projects for the actors after the 2027 finale, even as Garfield keeps denying Doomsday and Brand New Day while teasing Secret Wars.
The latest buzz, reported by Yahoo Entertainment, suggests the multiverse-era Spider-Men are not riding off into the sunset after the Multiverse Saga ends. For followers of celebrity breaking news, the claim reframes what fans thought was a one-and-done Avengers cameo arc.
Key Takeaways
- MyTimeToShineHello says Andrew Garfield and Tobey Maguire are planned for two MCU projects after Secret Wars.
- Both actors are reportedly returning for Secret Wars, but on separate storylines rather than a shared team-up.
- Garfield has bluntly denied Brand New Day and Doomsday while staying coy about Secret Wars.
- Related rumors point to Alfred Molina's Doc Ock and Anya Taylor-Joy's Magik joining the wider multiverse push.
- Marvel has not officially confirmed any of these casting claims.
What Did the Insider Claim About Andrew Garfield and Tobey Maguire?
According to Yahoo, MyTimeToShineHello posted on X that the Spider-Men's stories "will not end in Secret Wars as there are already plans for them to return in two more projects." That builds on earlier scoops tying both actors to the 2027 Avengers finale.
Marvel Studios has already lined up major names for Secret Wars, including Robert Downey Jr. as Doctor Doom and the Russo Brothers behind the camera. The film is scheduled for December 17, 2027, and is billed as the final chapter of Phase Six and the Multiverse Saga.
How Would Secret Wars Differ From Spider-Man: No Way Home?
MyTimeToShineHello previously reported that Andrew Garfield's Spider-Man "will get to fight an alien in Avengers Secret Wars," a callback to a wish his character voiced in No Way Home. The insider also claimed Maguire and Garfield "will both return in Avengers Secret Wars but this time they'll be separated."
That would mark a sharp shift from No Way Home, where Garfield, Maguire, and Tom Holland shared extensive screen time as a three-Spider-Man team. If the rumor holds, Secret Wars may split the legacy heroes across different corners of the multiverse instead of reuniting them on one battlefield.
What Has Andrew Garfield Said About Returning to Marvel?
Garfield has been emphatic about projects he says he is not doing. When asked about Spider-Man: Brand New Day and Avengers: Doomsday, he told interviewers, "No, unequivocally f—ing no." He has sounded far less definitive about Secret Wars.
During an MTV interview, Garfield teased, "See, what it is, is this a tell? Or what is it? You'll find out!" He also joked on Heart Radio that fans may still ask him about Spider-Man when he turns 90. For now, his public comments leave Secret Wars as the one door he has not fully closed.
Could Doc Ock and Other Spider-Man 2 Faces Return Too?
Separate reports tied to the same rumor cycle suggest Marvel is looking beyond the Spider-Men themselves. IMDb flagged an update citing MyTimeToShineHello that Alfred Molina may reprise Doctor Octopus in Avengers: Doomsday, potentially alongside sequences set in Tobey Maguire's universe.
GeekTyrant notes that Molina still has one film left on his original three-picture Marvel deal from Spider-Man 2 and told Variety he would return if asked, though he doubts it will happen. The same IMDb roundup also claimed Kevin Feige is interested in bringing Anya Taylor-Joy back as Magik from The New Mutants. None of these returns are confirmed by Marvel Studios.
Spider-Man: Brand New Day opens July 31, Avengers: Doomsday follows on December 18, and Secret Wars closes the saga on December 17, 2027. Until Marvel makes official announcements, treat every Spider-Man and multiverse rumor as speculation — even when the actors themselves seem to enjoy keeping fans guessing.