Luxury Real Estate & Dream Homes · Penelope Grant · 9 November 2026

425 million Nantucket home sale sets $42.5M island record

425 million Nantucket home sale sets $42.5M island record

A harbor-front 425 million Nantucket home known as Blue Waters has sold for $42.5 million at 57 Hulbert Avenue, setting a new island residential record. The Brant Point deal edges out Dave Portnoy’s $42 million 2023 purchase and ranks as Massachusetts’ second-highest home sale.

Key Takeaways

What sold for a record price on Nantucket?

According to Boston.com, the harbor-front house at 57 Hulbert Avenue—known as “Blue Waters”—sold for $42.5 million. The 6,393-square-foot property sits in Brant Point, a prized waterfront pocket overlooking Nantucket Harbor.

The Wall Street Journal reported the roughly 6,400-square-foot house has eight bedrooms on 0.62 acres, with direct beach and harbor access. The property was not listed on the public market when it closed.

Who owned the Brant Point estate before the sale?

Designed by architect William Edgar Shepherd in the 1930s, Blue Waters was once a Minshall family summer home, according to the Nantucket Historical Association. Later owners included George and Ethel Vigouroux before the Fife family took over.

Sellers are members of the Fife family, who owned the home since 1972. Relatives include Barbara Fife, New York City’s former deputy mayor for planning and development from 1990 to 1993. Her husband, investor Martin Fife, died in 2004. The buyer’s identity was not disclosed.

Jeanne Hicks of Lee Real Estate represented the sellers and told the Globe she was “honored to be part of such an important transaction,” declining further details. Chandra Miller of Maury People Sotheby’s International Realty represented the buyer.

How does the deal compare with other Massachusetts records?

The closing dethrones Portnoy’s $42 million waterfront compound as Nantucket’s top residential sale. Statewide, it remains second to “Great Point” on Martha’s Vineyard, a multi-parcel deal totaling $43 million earlier this year through $27 million and $16 million abutting sales.

Boston.com notes a $45 million Nantucket listing could soon eclipse both the island and state marks if it sells. For more luxury market coverage, see BlasterPost’s Luxury Real Estate & Dream Homes hub.

Brant Point has drawn notable residents, including former Secretary of State John Kerry on Hulbert Avenue and Suzy Hilfiger. Amid recent eight-figure island deals—including a nearby home that resold last month for $35 million—the record reflects strong demand for scarce waterfront homes.

← Open in blast feed